Artificial intelligence will not replace thinking - but it can effectively disguise the lack of it. This guide encourages a rethink of how learning outcomes are verified in the age of AI. It demonstrates why a correct answer or a polished submission is no longer enough to assess students' actual knowledge and skills. It offers practical guidance on incorporating problem-solving processes, reasoning behind decisions, and self-reflection into assessment. Finally, it helps establish clear AI usage policies and design tasks that demand genuine cognitive effort.